Top Bottom Home Site Map Topic Previous Next Top
philjohn.com
philjohn.com
home \ reviews \ tv shows \ babylon 5 & crusade \ index and show review
 Babylon 5

Section Index


Essays
1. On Babylon 5
2. Myths and Fiction
Selected Bibliography


Episode Guides & Reviews
Show Review Babylon 5
Episode Guide Babylon 5
Show Review Crusade
Episode Guide Crusade


Other
Babylon 5 Links



  What's Related  
  Subsequent Pages - Reviews  
  Subsequent Pages - Babylon 5  
Show Review & Index
  in association with amazon.com 
In Association with Amazon.com
 






IMDb/Babylon 5

BABYLON 5
1993-1999 · episode guide

At first, I just watched the pilot and the first episode, and I didn't really like it. It seemed to be not that interesting, it even seemed lame and boring, nothing compared to the almighty Star Trek I was used to at those times.

Hmm. Some time later I switched it on again, following the second season irregularly and without much interest at first, until I couldn't get away. Is there a term for this? Addiction? I don't know, but suddenly Babylon 5 really had become one of my favorite shows (I dare not say I have 'the' favorite show, because they are all very different and one really shouldn't compare them).

But what - in retrospect - made me come near a show that I at first neglected? Well, there are shows whose pilot is quite nice when it is the only thing you know about it. For instance the Star Trek pilots - if one knows some episodes from the late seasons, one nearly doesn't recognize that this old stuff belongs to the rest of the series. So I came to the conclusion to forget about the B5 pilot, too (by the way, the pilot from 'Space: Above and Beyond' also is quite bad compared to the series, especially the first hour). What is different in B5 compared to Star Trek? The story arcs, the persons, the general feeling. The crew has become nearly perfectly fit together by the third and fourth season (which is also true for DS9, but the other Treks really suffer from main character syndrome, and TNG of course from Wesley Crusher).

B5 doesn't have a 'harmless' story arc, it doesn't just have a nice crew, there is conflict between the persons (another thing parallel to DS9), and the music is great. The visual effects look quite nasty at the beginning, but one gets used to it - also because there is much more to be seen than in Star Trek.

However, B5 also suffers from its own structure. There aren't really any episodes that stand alone and that one could refer to a friend without the need for explanation. This is the point where shows like The X-Files or the Star Trek shows are easier to handle, but latest DS9 tendencies seem to deny even this.

Would I say that any of the two - B5 or Trek - is better or worse than the other? No! Never! Because I don't see the reason within this silly dispute. I really enjoy both, because there are things which make any one of the shows a little different from each other, and this makes it interesting. And to those Star Trek fans who are already on a crusade against B5: Ever heard of IDIC? Infinite Diversity in Infinite Combinations? You haven't forgotten your Surak, have you? There is plenty of room for both shows (counting the Trek shows as one) as there is room for DS9 and VGR. (Same argumentation of course for those who are on a crusade against Star Trek - fight the Shadows in your own universe, and do not let them infiltrate the Federation!)

But then, it's only television, all of them, and there should be no need to get aggressive. Live and let live, that's the combined message of B5 and Star Trek.

PJK
February 3rd, 1998







IMDb/Crusade

CRUSADE
1999-... · episode guide

Science fiction is a very delicate road to go. Most so-called sf shows and movies are rather claiming to be something they - in fact - aren't any more, which counts for most of Star Trek, especially for DS9, and also for Babylon 5. Crusade now gets half the way back to what sf once was all about, to science fiction, featuring the exploration of something new, the actual boldly going where no one has gone before. Partly.

The rest is an innovative look at the B5 universe, from an even darker and more shadowy corner of the universe, with a strange twist of humor which B5 was so desperately lacking most of the time. Crusade truely tries to be innovative, most obviously with its music, and it succeeds, at least most of the time, that is, mostly towards the end of its 13 episodes.

The very best episode, which may be an easy choice in so few, has to be the splendid X-Files parody 'Visitors From Down the Street' (episode 12). Having seen this, it is truly regrettable for this series to have reached its end, especially with those last four episodes in mind. This could have been so much of an inspiration to the entire genre, a thrilling ride and a departure from conservative science fiction like modern-day Star Trek. At least, we have Farscape now.

Crusade was fresh, unspoilt, promising. And now, dead. There's yet a story to be completed. Where are you going now, B5?

PJK
May 20th, 2001





© Phil John Kneis. all rights reserved   ·   philjohn.com - internet diary · poetry · serial photography

philjohn.com
pjkx.com
The Arts Circle